One of the most soul-sapping parts of being a movie reviewer is sitting through the procession of practically identical romantic comedies which Hollywood continues to gob forward each and every year with tireless, and completely misplaced, enthusiasm. My Best Friends Wedding would appear, at the outset at least, to be a prime example of just such a film: its about a 20-something gal who realises shes madly in love with her closest man-friend, just as hes about to marry someone else. And, just to hammer home the point that this looks like its going to be as formulaic a rom-com as youll get, it even stars Julia bloody Roberts in the lead role. With all of that in mind, it was with a sense of deep downright disinterest that I placed this disc into my DVD player.
I was wrong. Though far from a comic masterpiece, writer Roland Bass has managed to produce a flick which manages to stay true to its generic roots AND contain healthy helpings of sharpness and originality at the same time. The first 45 minutes, in which the premise is set-up, Roberts character Julianne drones on about her romantic epiphany, the object of her desire (Dermot Mulroney) is unveiled as exactly the sort of handsome-but-charmless safe-zoid youd expect, and we meet a ditzy Cameron Diaz as her lurve rival, are only there to lull us into a false sense of security. You see, as Julianne grows more and more desperate to split the pair of them up, her behaviour becomes, frankly, bang out of order, and suddenly us viewers are left with an unexpected dilemma: could it really be that the character we all thought we were supposed to be rooting for is actually a bit of a bitch? Thats perhaps a slightly extreme way of putting it but, nonetheless, its around the same time we realise this that we also realise we might also have a half-decent film on our hands.
My Best Friends Wedding isnt brilliantly cast: Roberts and Diaz both know the ropes, but Mulroney is an empty-eyed wooden sculpture fit only for appearing in Cuprinol commercials. Neither is it what you might call hilarious: aside from a couple of mildly chortlesome moments, many of the scenarios it throws up are more toe-curlingly uncomfortable than laugh-out-loud funny. But Bass has clearly put a lot of thought into writing his screenplay, and it pays off with some unexpected subversions and a story thatll keep you guessing right to the end. Will Julianne get her man and, more to the point, should we even want her to? Its the latter question, rather than the former, which lifts this flick above the average.