Mamma Mia! is the kind of movie you know going in whether or not youre going to like it. Two prerequisitesmust love ABBA and must love musicals. And really, knowing that its a film (based on the stage play of the same name) thats entire plot revolves around fusing ABBAs poppy concoctions with a perky little love story, are you really going in looking for high art?
Back in the day, Donna Sheridan (Meryl Streep) really got around, and her about-to-be-married daughter Sophie (Amanda Seyfried) has learned, from her mothers old diary, that one of three men could be her biological father. Determined to discover the truth and be led down the aisle by her true dad, Sophie has invited the three clueless prospects (Pierce Brosnan, Colin Firth, and Stellan Skarsgård) to her big fat Greek wedding, much to the chagrin of her mother. Dancing and singing ensue.
Fans of musicals are a different type of people. I myself am one, so I accept and adore the oft-hated conventions that infuse the genrethe breaking into song for no reason, the usually thin plots whose main reasons for being are usually to induce more singing, the bright shiny costumes and colors. Mamma Mia! has no shortage of any of those elements. Plus, with the ABBA component, its even happier than usual in this singing world of love lost and love found. But for all the naysayers, the critics who reviled this movie as one of the worst of 2008, youre missing the point.
Of course its campy, over-acted, and slightly shrill at times when Donna and her friendsor Sophie and her friendsget together and squeal away about something. And of course Pierce Brosnan cant sing. But the movies fun, Streep (and most of the rest of the cast) CAN sing, and you get the feeling while watching that even if the cast knew they were working on something that wasnt quite up to the status of Doubtor heck, even Hairspraythat they were having a blast. This is especially evident in the scenes involving Christine Baranski and Julie Walters as Donnas friends Tanya and Rosie; both hit their best friend roles running and give them their all. Which is actually one aspect of the film that can be seen as either a positive or negative, depending on where you come down on the whole musical subjectmuch of the film reflects the melodramatic and overly done style thats needed to reach the back of the auditorium, which isnt really necessary on film and can come off as loud and off-putting. My take? Who cares? Grab a feather boa, sing along, and lighten up for a bit.